The So What Shift: Modal Jazz Moving Up a Half Step and Back
What happens when a tune has only two chords and refuses to cadence? You get the So What shift: i7-bii7, or Dm7 Ebm7 in D minor, also called the Dorian half-step shift. In the Nashville Number System that's 1m(7) b2m(7). It's the defining form of modal jazz. Here are both chords in five keys, with audio.
A Form, Not a Loop
Don't treat this like a two-chord vamp. It's a large form across 32 bars, AABA, and the Ebm7 belongs to the B section. With four equal sections of 8 bars, that means:
- A, bars 1 to 8: Dm7
- A, bars 9 to 16: Dm7
- B, bars 17 to 24: Ebm7
- A, bars 25 to 32: Dm7
So you spend 16 bars on one chord before anything changes.
| Song | Artist | Section | Chords | Key |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| So What | Miles Davis | AABA form, B section | Dm7 Ebm7 | D minor |
| Impressions | John Coltrane | AABA form, B section | Dm7 Ebm7 | D minor |
So What and Impressions share this layout, both in D minor.
Move the Whole Mode Up a Fret
Each section is in Dorian: D Dorian on Dm7, Eb Dorian on Ebm7. So the whole mode moves up a half step, then back. Nothing functions as a cadence, and the sudden move itself is the only harmonic event.
That gives you a clear exercise. Learn a Dorian shape around fret 5 with D as the root. Improvise for 16 bars, shift everything up one fret for 8, then come back for the last 8. Your fingers do the same thing in a new place, and you can listen for the jolt: D Dorian and Eb Dorian only share F and C.
From C minor the pair reads Cm7 Dbm7, and Dbm7 is the chord from outside the key. Spelled out it's Db Fb Ab Cb, with no note in common with Cm7, which is C Eb G Bb. The same is true of Dm7 and Ebm7.
For more on staying in one mode for a long stretch, read about modal chord progressions.
So What Chord Progression: Chords and Audio in C, G, D, A and E
Press play to hear each key. The diagrams show the shapes used in the audio, and every chord links to its full page.
More progressions like this one
- Dorian shuttle: Cm F
- Dorian i-bVII-IV: Cm Bb F
- Minor i-bIII-IV: Cm Eb F
- Dorian i-bIII-bVII-IV: Cm Eb Bb F
FAQ
What are the two chords of So What in each key?
In C minor: Cm7 Dbm7. In G minor: Gm7 Abm7. In D minor: Dm7 Ebm7. In A minor: Am7 Bbm7. In E minor: Em7 Fm7.
What is the form of So What by Miles Davis?
It is a 32-bar AABA form in D minor. The A sections sit on Dm7, in D Dorian, and the B section moves up a half step to Ebm7, in Eb Dorian.
Is Impressions the same progression as So What?
Yes. Impressions by John Coltrane uses the same AABA layout with the same two chords, Dm7 and Ebm7, with the shift in the B section.
Why is there no cadence in the So What changes?
Neither chord works as a dominant leading to the other. The sudden half-step move, from one Dorian to the next, is the only harmonic event.