The Chromatic Lament Bass, from Dido's Lament to Led Zeppelin
Forget the chords for a moment. Play the open A string, then frets 4, 3, 2 and 1 of string 6, and finish on the open low E. You've just played A G# G F# F E, the chromatic lament bass, and with chords on top that's i-V/7-i/b7-IV/6-bVI-V: Am E/G# Am/G D/F# F E in A minor.
You'll also see it called the chromatic fourth, and the line does cover a fourth, from A down to E, one half step at a time. In the Nashville Number System it's 1m 5/7 1m/b7 4/6 b6 5.
In C minor the chords are Cm G/B Cm/Bb F/A Ab G. Three of those fall outside the key: G/B and G have a B natural, and F/A has an A natural, where C minor has Bb and Ab. Hear it and see the diagrams in five keys.
Two Passing Notes in a Natural Minor Line
Strip out G# and F# and you're left with A G F E, the plain natural minor walk of the Andalusian cadence. This line fills it in with those two chromatic passing notes, so the bass falls from tonic to dominant with no step bigger than a half step.
Wikipedia describes this as the chromatic form of the lament bass, long associated with grief in opera. Play it slowly, bass alone, and see if you hear why.
Same Line, Different Chords on Top
Each chord is only a step on the way down. The bass line is the identity, and the upper chords can vary. Look how the line and the chords change across these four pieces:
| Song | Artist | Section | Chords | Key |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dido's Lament | Henry Purcell | ground bass | bass G F# F E Eb D | G minor |
| Stairway to Heaven | Led Zeppelin | intro | Am G#aug C/G D/F# Fmaj7 G Am | A minor |
| Babe I'm Gonna Leave You | Led Zeppelin | intro and verse | Am C/G D/F# F E | A minor |
| While My Guitar Gently Weeps | The Beatles | verse | Am Am/G F#m7b5 Fmaj7 | A minor |
- Dido's Lament: Henry Purcell's ground bass in G minor, G F# F E Eb D. That's all six notes, the same line as the G minor version here, and only the bass is given here.
- Stairway to Heaven: the intro goes Am G#aug C/G D/F# Fmaj7, so the bass comes down five notes, A to F. Then it turns around, through G to Am.
- Babe I'm Gonna Leave You: Am C/G D/F# F E. It reaches E like the line here, but it skips the G#.
- While My Guitar Gently Weeps: Am Am/G F#m7b5 Fmaj7. No G# here either, and the line stops on F.
The Same Three Notes on Top
That last one has a lovely secret. Spell the chords out: Am is A C E, Am/G adds G underneath, F#m7b5 is F# A C E, and Fmaj7 is F A C E. Every chord contains A, C and E, so you could hold those three notes and let the bass do everything.
Now put that next to Babe I'm Gonna Leave You, which plays C/G where the line here has Am/G. The bass is the same G, and the only note missing is A. Small choices like that change the colour while the line keeps its name.
Practice It in Three Passes
- Play the bass notes alone, one per bar, at 60 bpm.
- Add the chords and watch the end of the line. F to E shares no notes at all, though the bass moves only one fret.
- Try the chords from each song over the same bass, and pick your favourite.
The first four notes, A G# G F#, also make the minor line cliché, where the chord on top stays Am. If this mood is what you're after, there are more sad chord progressions to explore.
Chromatic Lament Bass: Chords and Audio in C, G, D, A and E
Press play to hear each key. The diagrams show the shapes used in the audio, and every chord links to its full page.
More progressions like this one
- Picardy third ending: Cm Fm G C
- Minor circle of fifths: Cm Fm Bb Eb Ab Dm7b5 G Cm
- Minor i-iv-bVII: Cm Fm Bb
- Minor i-bIII-bVI-bVII: Cm Eb Ab Bb
FAQ
What is a chromatic lament bass?
It is a bass line that falls by half steps from the tonic to the dominant, such as A G# G F# F E in A minor. The chords on top can change, because the line is what identifies it. It is also called the chromatic fourth.
How does the chromatic lament bass transpose to other keys?
In C minor: Cm G/B Cm/Bb F/A Ab G. In G minor: Gm D/F# Gm/F C/E Eb D. In D minor: Dm A/C# Dm/C G/B Bb A. In A minor: Am E/G# Am/G D/F# F E. In E minor: Em B/D# Em/D A/C# C B.
How is the chromatic lament different from the Andalusian cadence?
The Andalusian cadence walks down the natural minor line, A G F E. The chromatic lament adds G# and F# as passing notes, so the bass falls by half steps all the way.
Does Stairway to Heaven use the chromatic lament bass?
Yes, in the intro. Led Zeppelin play Am G#aug C/G D/F# Fmaj7, so the bass falls from A to F, then the chords G and Am take it back up.
Which songs use a descending chromatic bass line in A minor?
Stairway to Heaven and Babe I'm Gonna Leave You by Led Zeppelin both use it, and so does While My Guitar Gently Weeps by The Beatles, in the verse.