Puff Schema With Major III: One Raised Note Between I and IV
Open, first fret, second fret. That's what the fourth string does through the open shapes of G B7 C, a little climb hiding in the middle of the chords. This is the puff schema with a major III, I-III7-IV, or 1 3(7) 4 in the Nashville Number System.
You'll also see it as I-III-IV, since the seventh is an optional colour, and Open Music Theory writes it I-III#-IV. In the key of C the chords are C E7 F, and E7 is the outsider, because its G# isn't in C major. Go and hear it in five keys, then come back to the line.
Raise One Note, Get a New Line
The plain puff schema is I-iii-IV, all chords from the key. Raise the third of that middle chord, and the minor iii turns major. In the key of G, D becomes D#. Now look at the inner voice:
- G: D, the 5 of the key, on the open fourth string.
- B7: D#, the sharp 5, on the first fret.
- C: E, the 6, on the second fret.
That's a chromatic line, 5 to sharp 5 to 6. Try this: strum the three chords, then pick only the fourth string, then strum again and see if you can still follow it. In the key of C the same line is G, G#, A.
B7 Promises One Thing, C Delivers Another
B7 sounds like V of vi. In the key of G, that means it looks ready to resolve to E minor. It goes to C instead, with the bass rising just a half step from B, so you get a small deceptive resolution in the middle of a major-key phrase.
You can test it. Play G B7, then stop and sing the chord you expect next. Now play the C and compare. Then play the same thing, end on E minor and compare the two.
With or Without the Seventh
The seventh is a colour you can take or leave. Four of these five songs use it and Creep doesn't.
| Song | Artist | Section | Chords | Key |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Creep | Radiohead | whole song | G B C | G major |
| Imagine | John Lennon | chorus | C E7 F | C major |
| Space Oddity | David Bowie | verse | C E7 F | C major |
| The Air That I Breathe | The Hollies | verse | B D#7 E | B major |
| Make You Feel My Love | Adele | bridge | Bb D7 Eb | Bb major |
Imagine and Space Oddity both sit in the key of C, so C E7 F is what you play, in the chorus for John Lennon and in the verse for David Bowie. Creep by Radiohead runs on G B C through the whole song, with plain triads. It has its own page as the Creep progression, I-III-IV-iv, where a minor iv follows the IV.
The other two need a capo if you want open shapes. The Air That I Breathe by The Hollies plays B D#7 E in the verse, and Make You Feel My Love is Bb D7 Eb in the bridge. With a capo on the fourth fret the first one becomes G B7 C, and on the third fret the second one does too, so one set of open shapes covers The Hollies and Adele.
To see the raised chord on its own, without the IV, go to the I-III chromatic mediant.
Puff Schema with Major III: Chords and Audio in C, G, D, A and E
Press play to hear each key. The diagrams show the shapes used in the audio, and every chord links to its full page.
Longer progressions that contain it
- Creep progression: C E F Fm
More progressions like this one
- Minor plagal cadence: Fm C
- Chromatic mediant I-bIII: C Eb
- Chromatic mediant I-III: C E
- Major line cliche: C Cmaj7 C7 F
FAQ
Can you list the puff schema with major III by key?
In C major: C E7 F. In G major: G B7 C. In D major: D F#7 G. In A major: A C#7 D. In E major: E G#7 A.
What is the difference between I-iii-IV and I-III-IV?
The third of the middle chord is raised, so the minor iii becomes a major III. That creates a chromatic inner line, 5 to sharp 5 to 6: G, G#, A in the key of C.
Why does E7 to F sound like a surprise?
E7 sounds like V of vi, the chord that would lead to A minor. Moving to F instead gives a small deceptive resolution, with the bass rising only a half step.
Do I need the seventh on the III chord?
No, the seventh is an optional colour. Imagine and Space Oddity play C E7 F, while Creep by Radiohead plays plain G B C.